How Does Puffy Mattress Compare To Pillowtop Mattress? Common Question And Answers

Helen Skeates
Helen Skeates
11 min read

When you know how Puffy mattress compares to pillowtop mattress, you’ll be able to answer the question more readily. This post will go over the features and layers of both beds to help you decide which one is best for you. As a comparison, we’ll also take a look at the hybrid versions from Puffy.

Are you interested in comparing Puffy to another brand? As an example, we’ve already written on the differences between DreamCloud and Puffy. If you’re looking for alternatives to Puffy, feel free to peruse our blog.

How to choose a mattress

You must be able to separate the true benefits of a mattress from the hype in order to successfully shop. In our guide to choosing a mattress, we show you how to determine whether a mattress will offer enough support and pressure relief for your body, what size mattress to choose, when to buy, and what to ask the salesperson (or live-chat attendant) to figure out if a mattress is durable.

Puffy Mattress Comparison (2022 Update) - Mattress Clarity

What to know about mattress types

There are two types of mattresses to choose from when it comes to bedding: foam mattresses and innerspring mattresses. What about a “hybrid” vehicle? Latex may be an option. For those who want to learn more about mattress kinds, we’ve broken down the benefits and cons of what’s inside that veiled rectangle.

Is the Puffy a Good Mattress for You?

To begin, let me explain who the Puffy Original mattress is most suited for.

Who I recommend the Puffy Mattress for

  • The Puffy’s combination of pressure alleviation and support should be ideal for back sleepers.
  • If you’re prone to pressure points and prefer the softness of memory foam, the Puffy might be right for you. It was created with the goal of relieving discomfort at pressure points and adapting to the wearer’s body.
  • The Puffy has the potential to be an excellent mattress for children. It has a stain-resistant fabric and just the appropriate amount of cushion and support for people with lighter frames in any position they choose to sleep in.

Who I don’t recommend the Puffy Mattress for

  • Puffy is not recommended for those who must sleep on their stomachs since the material is too soft to provide adequate support. Instead, I’d recommend one of our stomach-sleeping mattresses.
  • Similarly, the Puffy will not provide adequate support for heavy sleepers (those weighing more than 250 pounds). My recommendation is to look for an innerspring mattress with a thicker layer of foam to provide additional support. Our list of the best mattresses for hefty people may offer a few options for heavier individuals.
  • Mattresses that are more sensitive may be preferable for those who sleep in a variety of positions. The Puffy’s body-contouring memory foam makes you feel like you’re “hugged by” rather than “on top of” the mattress.

How Firm is the Puffy Mattress?

Keeping in mind that firmness is subjective, let’s get started. The firmness or softness of a mattress will vary depending on a person’s weight, shape, and favorite posture while they sleep. It was important to me to have a true sense of how firm the Puffy mattress was, so I questioned a wide spectrum of employees. 6.5 out of 10 is the industry standard for medium firmness.

How Does Puffy Mattress Compare To Pillowtop Mattress - Krostrade

After sinking through the top layer of the Puffy, I was able to feel the transition layer’s support. This mattress is softer than usual, according to my mattress firmness rating of 6 out of 10.

What Is The Difference Between The Puffy Mattress And A Pillowtop Mattress?

Puffy mattress


Two inches of Puffy’s Cooling Cloud foam, infused with gel, make up the mattress’s first layer. The base is six inches of high-density foam, with additional two inches of cooling foam underneath. With its cooling foam layers compared to standard memory foam beds, you won’t have to worry about how you can keep the Puffy mattress cooler.


The medium firmness of the Puffy mattress makes it an excellent choice for people who sleep in a variety of positions. On the other hand, if you’re looking for a certain level of firmness, this mattress falls between between a 6 and an 8. The Puffy mattress is a good option for people who aren’t sure what firmness of mattress they prefer.


The Puffy mattress is a medium-firm mattress, so you can easily keep your spine in a neutral position. In order to avoid sinking into the bed and encouraging an abnormal curvature of the spine, the mattress isn’t excessively soft. Puffy mattress’ cooling cloud and firm core support foam layers adjust to your body’s movements throughout the night so you can sleep comfortably.

Pressure relief

Even with the lack of sinkage, the Puffy mattress nevertheless provides some pressure-relieving padding for your body. Preventing pressure points on the back, shoulder, and hip from becoming inflamed may alleviate discomfort and agony. Aside from keeping the mattress cool, the second layer of foam provides pressure relief and cradles your body.

Pillowtop mattress


This mattress is referred to as a pillow top because of its top layer of cushioning. A pillow top mattress features a cushioned layer that separates it from the mattress surface, in contrast to a Puffy mattress that has no discernible extra material on top. A pillow top mattress, on the other hand, might include materials such as latex foam, down, cold, cotton, or even fiberfill in addition to memory foam as part of its plush layer.

If you’d want to know how long a pillow top mattress lasts, we’ve written a separate post on that.


In terms of softness, a pillow top mattress is one of the most popular on the market. As a result, back and stomach sleepers will benefit most from the Puffy mattress’ firmer texture. On the other hand, those who prefer to sleep on their sides and are light in weight would enjoy the pillow top mattress’s soft texture.


The foundation layer determines how well a pillow top bed will support you. Pillow top mattresses often have a coil or innerspring support layer beneath them, so you can count on them to provide the same level of support as these more traditional mattresses. If the pillow top layer is prone to sagging, it may nevertheless be able to maintain your body’s level.

To help you select the greatest pillow top mattress, learn more about what makes one.

Pressure relief

In terms of pressure alleviation, a pillow top mattress is one of the greatest options. Similar to the Puffy mattress, it is good at adapting to the shape of the body when sleeping on it. If this is a key priority for you in a bed, you may want to consider a pillow top made of memory foam.

Pillowtop mattress vs Puffy Lux

As a medium-plush bed, the Puffy Lux is the most popular mattress from Puffy, and it is softer than the original Puffy mattress. Because of the Plush Dual Comfort foam, the Puffy Lux is equivalent to a pillow top even though it lacks a visible top cushion layer. It might also be as thick as a typical pillow top at 12 inches.

Pillowtop mattress vs Puffy Royal

As a medium-plush bed, the Puffy Lux is the most popular mattress from Puffy, and it is softer than the original Puffy mattress. Because of the Plush Dual Comfort foam, the Puffy Lux is equivalent to a pillow top even though it lacks a visible top cushion layer. It might also be as thick as a typical pillow top at 12 inches.

How Firm Are The Saatva And Puffy Mattresses?

The Puffy Lux is Puffy’s most popular mattress, and it is also softer than the original Puffy mattress because it is a medium-plush bed. With its Plush Dual Comfort foam, the Puffy Lux does have some comparisons to pillows with a visible top cushion layer. At 12 inches, it may be as thick as the normal pillow top.

A little stiffer than typical, the Puffy mattress was rated a 7/10. Our bodies were able to feel the transition and support layers beneath the bed’s soft comfort layer despite its thinness. Because of your weight and personal preferences, the firmness of every bed will vary slightly.

What Do The Saatva And Puffy Mattresses Feel Like?

Saatva’s innerspring sensation is complemented by the softness of its pillowtop. Dual layers of coils provide lots of bounce, responsiveness and body shaping with a pillow-top and microcoils. You won’t get caught on this mattress because it’s so effortless to get up and down from it.

Puffy vs Puffy Lux (2022 Update) - Personally Tested

The overall foam texture of the Puffy is well-balanced. This mattress contains a slow-moving memory foam on top that is balanced out by firmer and more responsive foams on the bottom layer. This bed should make it easy to switch positions.


There you have it! As a refresher, the Puffy mattress is firmer since it is medium-firm, whereas a pillow top mattress is always plusher because of its additional top padding. If you’ve chosen a high-quality pillow top, both beds should keep your body well-supported and reduce pressure points.

Hopefully, this guide has been helpful, and if you’re interested in purchasing a Puffy mattress, check out the current discount period.

Helen Skeates

Helen Skeates

Lorem Ipsum is simply dummy text of the printing and typesetting industry. Lorem Ipsum has been the industry's standard dummy text ever since the 1500s, when an unknown printer took a galley of type and scrambled it to make a type specimen book. It has survived not only five centuries, but also the leap into electronic typesetting, remaining essentially unchanged. It was popularised in the 1960s with the release of Letraset sheets containing Lorem Ipsum passages, and more recently with desktop publishing software like Aldus PageMaker including versions of Lorem Ipsum.