What Is The Firmest Mattress? Common Question And Answers

Helen Skeates
Helen Skeates
55 min read

Beds can be advertised as “soft” or “plush.” Our research has shown that many people prefer firmer mattresses. Those who weigh above 230 pounds may benefit from a mattress with a firmer feel, which provides more support and less sinkage. As a group, we found that those who slept on their backs or stomachs preferred mattresses that were firmer to support their lower backs and relieve pressure points in their spines.

Our top recommendations for the finest firm mattresses were chosen mostly for their firmness, but they also had to meet a number of other criteria, including longevity, temperature regulation, and edge support. There is no better group of people to conduct our in-person tests than those who work for the Sleep Foundation. Side, back, stomach, and combination sleepers make up the bulk of our eclectic group. We use their comments to evaluate mattresses for a variety of performance indicators and assign ratings that reflect the experiences of the vast majority of people who use them.


What Is The Firmest Mattress You Can Buy

High-quality construction and above-average performance distinguish each of these mattresses from the rest of the pack. The following sections provide in-depth information on the best firm mattresses we’ve identified. Continue reading for our in-depth buyer’s guide, which covers the benefits and drawbacks of firm mattresses, who they are best suited for, and what to expect in terms of price, lifespan, and performance.

Plank Luxe Hybrid

Cost: $799 – $1,499 per month

Type of Mattress: Hybrid

The trial will last 120 days (30-night requirement)

Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, Short Queen, Olympic Queen, King, Short King, RV King, California King, California King Split, Split California King.

Who it’s best for:

  • Sleepers who are too hot to handle
  • Those who sleep on their backs or stomachs
  • Those who want a mattress with a variety of firmness levels in one.


  • Add-on cooling panel can be purchased for an extra charge
  • Design that can be flipped between a hard and an extra-firm grip
  • In addition, there are choices for RVs and short queen mattresses.

There are two firmness levels on the Plank Luxe Hybrid: firm (seven) and extremely firm (nine). However, we also observed that the softer side of the mattress was quite solid and well-suited for persons who weigh more than 230 pounds, especially back and stomach sleepers.

What Is a Plush Mattress, and Do You Need One? - Casper Blog

What Materials Are Used to Create It

Two polyfoam layers sandwich a top layer of fiber padding on the Plank Luxe Hybrid’s firm side. This floor’s mild cushioning provided uniform weight distribution and minimal sinkage for our researchers’ test subjects. One of the underlying foam layers is omitted from the extra firm side. As a result, there was no sinkage at all on this surface for us to report. With a shared coil support core, our testers reported feeling substantial pushback anytime one of them climbed into or out of bed.

The entire mattress is protected by a quilted cotton-microfiber blend cover. During temperature control testing, we found that this material was fairly breathable and that air flowed smoothly through the coil layer. You may want to consider a mattress with a phase change panel sewed into both surfaces if you are a hot sleeper. Panels with a cooling effect were detected by our testers, which helped keep the mattress cool and limit the risk of overheating.

What Results Were Obtained?

The Plank Luxe Hybrid received the most positive feedback from back and stomach sleepers who weighed more than 230 pounds during our hands-on tests. However, some of our stomach sleepers in this weight range found the extra firm texture to be more comfortable.

We also praised the mattress’s edge support and portability. We were able to wander around the mattress without feeling trapped or confined, and each member felt secure when sitting on the edge of the mattress. The Plank Luxe Hybrid excelled in temperature regulation, especially with the phase-change panel upgrade.

For consumers in the contiguous United States, Brooklyn Bedding offers free shipping on orders of any size, including short queens and RV beds. Plank Luxe Hybrid mattresses come with a 120-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty.

To Sum It Up

For those who aren’t sure how firm they want their mattress, the Plank Luxe Hybrid offers a flippable design. For those of us who weigh more than 230 pounds, the mattress was a dream come true.

Firmer WinkBed

In the $1,149 to $2,049 range.

Mattresses with innersprings

The trial will last 120 days (30 night requirement)

Sizing Options: Twin, Full, Full XL, Queen, California King, and King Size

Who it’s best for:

  • Sleepers who enjoy the movement of innerspring coils
  • It is common for people to sleep or sit on the edge of their bed.
  • In order to ensure customer satisfaction, manufacturers offer a lifetime warranty.


  • Cushioning is provided with a plush Euro-top.
  • Dynamic support is provided by the coil system.
  • Guaranteed for life

The WinkBed is a high-end hybrid that comes in four different firmness options. If you’re looking for a mattress that is both supportive and firm, we recommend the Firmer WinkBed (7). When it came to testing for ease of movement and edge support, our crew was particularly impressed by the zoned coil system, which gave great reinforcement and pushback. Evenly contoured adaptable foam layers also help to alleviate lower back discomfort and hip pain.

What Materials Are Used to Create It

An adaptable polyfoam quilted into the cover is followed by a second layer of polyfoam. The firmness of the mattress didn’t deter our testers from noticing a velvety surface and deeper cushioning as their bodies acclimatized to the comfort system. To help disperse heat from the body, the second layer is laced with a cooling gel.

There are two regions where humans tend to carry more weight, the torso and the hips, that are supported by thicker coils in the core. Most of our test subjects only sank a few centimeters. Our side and back sleepers were most affected by this. Additionally, the coils are reinforced around the perimeter to prevent the edges from sinking in. The mattress is protected by a Tencel cover composed of eucalyptus-derived fabric. Because of its naturally breathable properties, we noted that the surface was cool to the touch.

What Results Were Obtained?

Back and stomach sleepers who weigh at least 130 pounds found the mattress most pleasant. The Firmer WinkBed was also a good choice for side sleepers who weighed more over 230 pounds. The Softer WinkBed (4) or the Luxury Firm WinkBed (6) may be more suitable for lighter folks who find this mattress excessively firm.

A 120-night trial period is included with each Firmer WinkBed. A WinkBed is exchangeable for a different firmness level at no additional cost in the event that you find this mattress to be too soft or too firm. The new model has a 60-night trial period. If you opt to keep your WinkBed, you’ll get a lifetime warranty against structural problems.

To Sum It Up

If you weigh more than 130 pounds, we recommend the Firmer WinkBed model. Because of this, the center support system is thicker and more stable, preventing your torso from sinking into the mattress.

Nolah Evolution 15 – Firm

One thousand nine hundred and ninety-nine dollars

Type of Mattress: Hybrid

The trial will last 120 days (30-night requirement)

Sizing Options: Twin, Full, Full XL, Queen, California King, and King Size

Who it’s best for:

  • Those who sleep on their backs or stomachs
  • Couples
  • Sleepers who are too hot to handle


  • Strong support with just the right amount of padding for a relaxing experience.
  • The use of a ventilated coil support core and a proprietary cooling cover reduces heat accumulation.
  • Targeted support and edge bolstering are provided by zoned coils

With three firmness levels to choose from, the Nolah Evolution 15 is the perfect luxury hybrid mattress for those who require extra support. In addition to the Euro-top surface cushioned with thick foam layers and a zoned coil system that pushes back against our testers’ heavier areas, this mattress is very well balanced and pleasant.

What Materials Are Used to Create It

The cover of the Evolution 15 is quilted with adaptable foam. A third layer of foam is then added on top of this. Our testers felt varied levels of cushioning and contouring as their bodies sank into the mattress because each layer is gradually denser from top to bottom. We didn’t see any heat accumulation because of the open-cell composition of these foams.

The thicker coils under the torso and hips of each team member, including those who weighed more than 230 pounds, provided a more stable platform for everyone. We were able to get on and off the mattress with less sinking and sagging at the edges thanks to the additional perimeter support. The entire mattress is covered in a cooling fabric cover.

What Results Were Obtained?

Back sleepers raved about the Evolution 15 throughout our testing. Those who weighed at least 130 pounds gave the mattress their highest praise, although people of all sizes gave it a “good” or “better” grade. Over 230-pound stomach sleepers particularly liked the firmness and support of the Evolution 15. If you’re a side sleeper, this mattress’ medium (5) or medium firm (6) varieties are definitely better options.

Another area where this mattress fared well for our testers was the ease of movement. A major problem with mattresses with thick layers of foam is that it’s difficult to move around on them because of the mattress’s stiffer feel and substantial coil pushback. Our other findings included stable perimeter support and constant cooling.

There is no shipping fee for clients in the 48 contiguous states. During a 30-night break-in period, buyers can return a mattress for a full refund if they are not satisfied. Customers can also save money by not participating in the sleep trial. A substantial lifetime warranty is included with every Evolution 15 purchase.

To Sum It Up

For a mattress with such a deep comfort system, the Evolution 15 is incredibly stable. Even though we didn’t sink too much when moving around the mattress or across the edges, the majority of our team’s back and stomach sleepers felt no pressure building because of the ample padding.


In the $699 to $1,499 range

Foam is the most commonly encountered mattress material.

The trial will last 120 days (30-night requirement)

Sizes: Twin, Full, Full XL, Full, Queen, King, Split California King, Short Full, Short Queen, Olympic Queen, Short King, RV King

Who it’s best for:

  • People who choose a firmer choice.
  • Those seeking a design that can be reversed in firmness
  • Those that value strong edge support highly


  • Design that can be flipped and has hard and extra firm settings
  • On the market, one of the firmest mattresses
  • Improves control of internal temperature by adding an optional cooling top panel.

Most of the flippable mattresses our team has evaluated have at least one surface that falls between between soft and medium. There are few better options for those who desire a hard mattress to sleep on every night than the Plank. If you’re looking for a surface that doesn’t give you any wiggle room at all, this might be it.

What Materials Are Used to Create It

TitanFlex polyfoam is sandwiched between layers of soft fibers quilted into the cover of the Plank’s firm side. TitanFlex is a “best of both worlds” material that blends the cushioning of standard foam with the responsiveness of latex. When moving over this side of the mattress, our reviewers experienced a lot of bounce. There is no TitanFlex on the side that is especially firm. This surface had very little to no contouring to it.

Between the two comfort systems is a high-density polyfoam support core. This layer provides outstanding stability on both sides, according to our testing. A phase change panel should be added to both sides of the mattress in order to keep you cool while you sleep. Sewn into the cover, this panel acts as a heat-sink and heat-exchanger. We noted a significant difference in cooling and heat dispersion between the Plank’s two sides, even though none of our testers felt unduly hot.

What Results Were Obtained?

A firmer mattress than the average, the Plank outperformed comparable all-foam beds in our tests. Our testers were able to travel across both surfaces with no sinkage since the edges felt extremely solid, especially on the extra firm side. Another feature that stood out during our testing was the significantly better than average cooling. No heat buildup was recorded even without phase change panels.

The firmer side of the Plank was favoured by the vast majority of our tasters. Our heavier back sleepers (up to 230 pounds) and stomach sleepers (up to 130 pounds) appreciated how well this mattress supported them. The extra firm side was likewise preferred by our team’s stomach sleepers, who collectively weighed over 230 pounds.

It’s possible to get a Plank in one of 14 different sizes. Choose from split California kings or Olympic queens for extra breadth when sharing an adjustable bed foundation with a loved one, as well as many RV-friendly mattress sizes, in addition to the six regular mattress sizes. With a 120-night sleep trial, the Brooklyn Bedding mattress comes with a money back guarantee. A 10-year warranty is included with the Plank if you decide to keep it.

To Sum It Up

The Plank doesn’t mess around when it comes to stiffness, as its name implies. If you’ve struggled to find a mattress that’s firm enough for you, this is the mattress for you!

Saatva Classic – Firm

From $887 to $2,296

Mattresses with innersprings

For $99, you get a 365-night trial with no strings attached.

Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Split King, California King, Split California King, and California King Split.

Who it’s best for:

  • who prefer the springy feel of an innerspring mattress, or
  • Extra lumbar support for those who require it.
  • Anyone desiring White Glove delivery for no additional cost


  • This product is obtainable in two different widths: 11.5 inches and 14.5 inches
  • Memory foam in the lumbar pad reduces pressure on the lower back, making it more comfortable.
  • Firm stability provided by coil-on-coil construction

Another luxury hybrid that comes in a variety of firmness levels is the Saatva Classic. We recommend the firm (8) feel if you’re searching for solid support and a reasonable amount of reactivity. This mattress has two layers of coils. Thus, our testers saw a large pushback and remarkable stability around the periphery.

What Materials Are Used to Create It

To begin, the Saatva Classic has a Euro-top surface that is padded with foam and fiber to keep it from feeling overly firm. The lumbar and hip pressure can be alleviated by placing a memory foam strip under your lower back. First, a transitional support layer of pocketed minicoils is used, followed by a support core consisting of recycled steel low-gauge hourglass coils.

For your Saatva Classic, you have a choice of two profiles. The 11.5-inch model has hourglass coils that are 4 inches in diameter, while the 14.5-inch model has hourglass coils that are 7 inches in diameter. Although both mattresses performed well in our hands-on mattress tests, we recommend the latter if you’re looking for additional support.

What Results Were Obtained?

The dual-coil architecture of the Saatva Classic allowed it to perform better than typical hybrids in a number of crucial categories throughout our tests. This was one of the most impressive aspects of the design. To ensure a cool surface, we used an organic cotton cover with both coils and a permeable organic cotton top layer. In addition, there was little sinkage at the borders, and none of us felt stuck as we moved across the top.

If you weigh more than 230 pounds and sleep on your back or stomach, the firm Saatva Classic mattress should be your best option. The soft (3) or medium firm (6) variants of this mattress may be better suited for those who weigh less than the average member of any of these categories.

A free White Glove delivery that includes the Saatva’s setup and removal of your old mattress is included with your order when you place it, thanks to Saatva. For the next 365 days, you can use the product and return it for a full refund minus $99 for the return pick-up. There is a lifetime warranty on the mattress in case of any problems.

To Sum It Up

Coil-on-coil construction gives the Saatva plenty of support where it’s needed, but the Euro-Top adds some softness where it’s needed. During our durability testing, the high-quality construction beat out the competitors by a wide margin.

DreamCloud Mattress

Minimum and maximum price ranges: $999 and $1,499

Type of Mattress: Hybrid

The trial will last for 365 days (30-night requirement)

Sizing Options: Twin, Full, Full XL, Queen, California King, and King Size

Who it’s best for:

  • All sleeping postures (back, side, stomach, combination)
  • Those who are prone to nighttime fevers
  • Those that weigh more than 130 pounds as they sleep


  • Mattresses with a medium-firm feel are suitable for a wide range of sleepers.
  • An exceptional 365-night sleep experiment
  • The plushness of the quilted cover is achieved without causing excessive body sink.

Most of the other mattresses on our list of best firm mattresses seem a little softer than the DreamCloud does. The comfort system’s high profile and thick foam layers contribute significantly to this. As a result, the mattress has a medium firm (6) feel that should be comfortable for people of all body types and sleeping positions.

What Materials Are Used to Create It

A cashmere-blend cover encases the entire mattress. DreamCloud’s cashmere is inherently breathable and moisture-wicking, so our testers experienced minimal heat retention while lying on the mattress. The DreamCloud is one of the thickest mattresses we’ve tested at 14 inches. Foam layers can be added without affecting coil support because to the additional height.

What Results Were Obtained?

The DreamCloud provided adequate support for both our back and stomach sleepers. Some of these sleepers found the mattress to be a little too thick and luxurious, but none of them reported considerable sinkage. As a result of our testing, the DreamCloud mattress also sleeps cool and is stable along its perimeter.

If you’re on a tight budget, the DreamCloud is an excellent choice thanks to its affordable pricing and free shipping to the 48 contiguous United States states. The 365-night sleep trial included with every transaction makes this mattress an excellent choice for anyone who wants more time to decide on a new bed. The mattress is also covered by a lifetime guarantee from DreamCloud.

To Sum It Up

The DreamCloud, in our opinion, is the ideal mattress for anybody above 130 pounds. Side sleepers benefit the most from the plush surface, which relieves pressure on sensitive areas without sinking too deeply.

Helix Twilight

From $699 to $1,449

Type of Mattress: Hybrid

There are a total of 100 nights in the trial (30-night requirement)

Sizing Options: Twin, Full, Full XL, Queen, California King, and King Size

Who it’s best for:

  • Couples
  • Those who find it difficult to get out of bed in the morning
  • Those who prefer to sleep on their sides


  • Edge support is improved with the use of pocketed coils around the perimeter.
  • A comforting, pressure-relieving layer of memory foam
  • Shipping is free to all fifty states.

For those who sleep on their sides, a firm mattress may not offer the right amount of support and cushioning for a good night’s rest. One of the more unusual examples is the Helix Twilight. In order to reduce discomfort in the shoulders and hips of our side sleepers, the mattress has two layers of foam that adapt to the body and distribute the weight evenly.

What Materials Are Used to Create It

Two layers of memory foam and polyfoam form the Twilight’s comfort system. This mattress is stiff, but the Twilight’s foam layers conformed moderately and evenly to our bodies. Pocketed coils with additional perimeter support are found in the support core. When sitting or sleeping at the edge of the mattress, we felt a lot of resistance.

The Helix Twilight Luxe, an overpriced variant, has a pillow-top surface as well as more foam cushioning for a more luxurious feel. Those on our staff who weighed up to 230 pounds found this mattress to be comfortable. The chest, stomach, and hips are all reinforced with thicker coils in Twilight Luxe models thanks to zonal support cores.

What Results Were Obtained?

The Twilight’s most comfy side sleepers weighted at least 130 pounds, according to our testing team. Back and stomach sleepers weighing 130 pounds or more and 130 to 230 pounds were also fans of the mattress. We believe the Twilight’s powerful coil structure is the reason none of our testers had any trouble travelling across its surface.

We’ve discovered that the Twilight maintains a comfortable temperature while sleeping. The coil layer and a breathable knit cover help to keep the surface at a pleasant temperature. When analyzing the mattress’s ability to regulate temperature, our experts found that there was very little buildup of heat on the surface. Additionally, we were impressed by how well the Twilight held up in our tests of mobility and edge support, thanks to its solid, responsive feel.

Each and every one of the United States’s fifty states can take advantage of Helix’s no-cost shipping. Twilight mattress purchases come with a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty against structural faults, which are covered by the warranty.

To Sum It Up

When compared to other firm mattresses, the Helix Twilight was the most comfortable for our heavier side sleepers. Assistive users benefited from the reinforced perimeter as well.

Bear Elite Hybrid – Extra Firm

Price: $1,865 – $2,798 Price Range

Type of Mattress: Hybrid

The trial will last 120 days (30-night break-in period)

Sizing Options: Twin, Full, Full XL, Queen, California King, and King Size

Who it’s best for:

  • Those who sleep on their backs or stomachs
  • Sleepers who are too hot to handle
  • Some people with sensitive areas prefer to sleep on a firm mattress.


  • With the Zoned Comfort System, you may get relief for your hips and shoulders where you need it.
  • Comfortable heat retention can be avoided by using breathable foams and aerated support cores.
  • Sleep trial for up to a month with a lifetime guarantee

The firmest of the Bear Elite Hybrid’s three patterns is rated an 8 out of 10 on our firmness scale. This mattress is designed for couples in a variety of ways. You and your spouse may make use of the entire mattress surface because of the mattress’s strong edge support, the responsiveness and ease of movement provided by the durable coil system, and the mattress’s outstanding temperature regulation provided by the cooling components.

Mattress Firmness Scale: Definition, Tips + Scale

What Materials Are Used to Create It

The comfort layer of the Elite Hybrid is made out of copper-infused memory foam, which naturally cools and dries the body. Additional cushioning is provided by a polyfoam transitional layer, which also maintains your body’s uniform support. Even though the mattress is firm and supportive, the foam layers distribute the weight evenly. So no sinkage was felt around the midsection because the polyfoam was separated into five different hardness zones.

Pocketed coils are sandwiched between a layer of high-density foam and a foundation layer of foam. Coils provide strong pushback to the zoned transitional foam, allowing all of our testers, including those weighing more than 230 pounds, to rest comfortably on the mattress. The Elite Hybrid is encased in a Celliant-blend fabric cover. Fibers of Celliant’s fabric are designed to be exceptionally permeable and efficient at dissipating heat. As a result, when we tested the mattress to see how well it controlled temperature, we noticed very little heat accumulation.

What Results Were Obtained?

More than half of our Elite Hybrid customers are over 230 pounds in weight, with the majority of them falling in the 130-pound range. We have received positive feedback from stomach sleepers ranging between 130 and 230 pounds. With a robust coil structure, the mattress was well-balanced and supportive, especially around the torso and hips, which are places where people tend to carry more weight.

In addition, we were impressed with the Elite Hybrid’s ability to regulate its own temperature. The copper-infused comfort layer, as well as the mattress’s internal coils and permeable cover, are responsible for the mattress’ exceptional cooling. During our edge support tests, we found that the mattress had minimal sinkage around the perimeter, making it easy for our testers to get around.

For consumers in the 48 contiguous states, Bear offers free shipping and a 120-night sleep trial. Any time after the 30-day break-in period, customers can return their mattresses. A lifetime structural fault warranty is included with Elite Hybrid sales.

To Sum It Up

Bear Elite Hybrid co-sleepers will be pleased. Foam and a strong coil structure provide excellent edge support, effortless movement across the surface, and good responsiveness for sex..”

GhostBed Classic

Price Range: $945 – $2,190

In the $945 to $2,190 price range

The trial is scheduled to last 101 nights. (30-Night Requirement)

Sizes: Twin, Full, Full XL, Queen, California King, Split King, and King

Who it’s best for:

  • Sleepers on their sides or backs who aren’t more than 230 pounds
  • Sleepers who are too hot to handle
  • Those easily disturbed by their partner’s movements


  • Those easily bothered by the actions of their partner
  • A breathable outer layer and a constant flow of air inside
  • Two complimentary pillows are included with each purchase.

We’ve tested a number of GhostBed mattresses, and all of them have received excellent results in our temperature control testing. With the GhostBed Classic, you get the best of both worlds: responsive latex and plush memory foam in one mattress. This mattress’s cool-to-the-touch cover and gel-infused transitional layer keep you from overheating as you sleep. The majority of the Classic’s layers are foam, which is notorious for its ability to absorb and hold onto heat.

What Materials Are Used to Create It

A latex comfort layer and a memory foam transition layer make up the GhostBed Classic. We noticed a lot of bounce when getting on and off the mattress because of how sensitive latex is. As their bodies sank into the mattress, our reviewers reported feeling deeply cushioned by the memory foam. Anyone on our team didn’t have a problem with heat retention because the foam was infused with cooling gel.

A high-density polyfoam foundation layer stabilizes the mattress and prevents you from sinking unduly into the mattress.. Ghost Ice, a special fabric used for the cover, is designed to drain heat and keep the user cool at all times. If you’re a hot sleeper or live in a place where the weather is consistently warm or humid, this mattress is a good option.

What Results Were Obtained?

When compared to other all-foam mattresses, the GhostBed Classic’s latex-foam structure gives it a unique sensation. It’s simple to move around on because of the springy top layer, but the cushioning and contouring provided by the underneath foam layers make it really comfortable. Our motion isolation testing also showed that our testers didn’t feel any motion transfer at all. The latex is sensitive, but the foam is excellent at absorbing movement.

All of our reviewers gave the Classic high scores. More than 230-pound side and back sleepers and under 130-pound stomach sleepers gave it the best reviews. If you fall into one of these categories and are bothered by back discomfort and/or pressure points, we highly recommend this mattress.

Both the mattress and the GhostPillows are offered at a reasonable price point. Orders shipped inside the 48 contiguous states are free of charge. An exhaustive 101-night trial and a 25-year warranty back up GhostBed’s Classic model.

To Sum It Up

The GhostBed’s star is its latex comfort layer. It improves the surface’s resiliency and responsiveness without compromising pressure relief. This mattress works best for people who sleep on their sides or backs.

Charles P. Rogers Estate SE

From $3,199 to $4,759

Type of Mattress: Hybrid

Duration: 100 nights

Sizing Options: Twin, Full, Full XL, Queen, California King, and King Size

Who it’s best for:

  • Sleepers who are too hot to handle
  • Those in search of a supportive mattress without sacrificing adequate pressure relief.
  • Those who prefer to sleep on their backs


  • The combination of latex and coils provides substantial support.
  • The body is softly cradled by layers of flexible latex.
  • Breathable construction keeps the mattress cool

The mattress stays cool thanks to its breathable design.

Breathable materials keep the mattress cool.

The Talalay latex-cushioned pillow-top surface of the Estate SE provides a luxuriously inviting feel as you sink into the bed. A second, slightly denser latex layer provides extra contouring while serving as a buffer between your body and the support core.. We noted a noticeable bounciness on the surface because latex is a naturally sensitive substance.

Pocketed coils and base polyfoam make up the support core. The coils are 14-gauge, meaning they are quite thick and sturdy. We felt considerable pushback when lying on the mattress, and most of our testers experienced little to no sinkage. A soft, breathable cotton cover encases the entire mattress. At 13 inches thick, the Estate SE is considered a high-profile model.

Pocketed coils and base polyfoam make up the support core. The coils are 14-gauge, meaning they are quite thick and sturdy. We felt considerable pushback when lying on the mattress, and most of our testers experienced little to no sinkage. A soft, breathable cotton cover encases the entire mattress. At 13 inches thick, the Estate SE is considered a high-profile model.

Coils and polyfoam form the core of the support structure. The coils are 14-gauge, which means they are very thick and robust. When we sat on the mattress, we felt a significant amount of pushback, and most of our testers reported no sinkage at all. Every part of the mattress is shielded from the elements by a comfortable cotton cover. A model with a thickness of 13 inches, the Estate SE, is a high-profile model.

We found the Estate SE to be a good option for consumers who require a bit additional support from their mattress in our research. Our team’s back and stomach sleepers, who each weighed at least 130 pounds, as well as our side sleepers, who each weighed in at least 230 pounds, all awarded the mattress high marks. Those who require pain or pressure relief but don’t like the close hug of foam can benefit from the mattress’s latex cushioning.

Estate SE’s cooling capabilities were also a big draw for us. Given that latex is an easily permeable substance, our temperature control tests revealed just a small amount of surface heat buildup. Because of the responsiveness of the latex, it was easy for our testers to move around the mattress, and the sturdy, low-gauge coils helped keep us from sinking too far into the mattress.

A 30-night break-in period is required for Charles P. Rogers’ 100-night sleep experiment. An additional 15-year prorated warranty is also included. To the 48 contiguous states, shipping is free.

To Sum It Up

For those who require a little pressure relief, the Charles P. Rogers Estate SE’s latex layers are the perfect compromise between firmness and comfort.

Why You Can Trust Us

Every mattress we test has a firmness rating assigned to it. From 1 (softest) to 10 (hardest), we utilize a 10-point scale (firmest). Only mattresses with a firmness rating of 6 (medium firm) or higher were considered for our top recommendations. These include mattresses that are specifically intended for a firmer sensation, as well as flippable models having at least one firm surface, and mattresses that are available in a variety of firmness levels.

How We Evaluated These Mattresses

Before deciding on our final picks, we personally tried out several different mattresses. Based on the weight and principal sleeping position of our testers, our findings should be representative of the vast majority of people, regardless of their personal preferences. The comfort and general support of a firm mattress were the primary considerations when compiling this list. We also factored in the cost of a product when making recommendations for those on a tight budget.

Check out our product study methodology below to discover more about the criteria we used to assess and rate firm mattresses:

  • How well a mattress absorbs and prevents movement from spreading across its surface is referred to as motion isolation. Couples and anyone who share a bed with someone else should pay special attention to motion isolation because transfer might create sleep difficulties.
  • Temperature Control: The ability of a mattress to resist overheating and maintain a pleasant sleep surface temperature is one of our primary criteria for evaluating temperature control. Sleeping on a mattress with active cooling technology or layers that encourage airflow and breathability can keep you cool at night.
  • In many cases, pressure building in the shoulders and hips can be alleviated through the use of a supportive mattress. Having a mattress that cushions the middle of your body and keeps you on an even plane will ease this discomfort and prevent new pressure spots from growing.
  • The smell of off-gassing is typical in new mattresses, especially ones made of foam and other synthetic materials, and it can be difficult to mask. Mattresses with more chronic off-gassing can cause a bad night’s sleep if they don’t diminish within a few days.
  • It will be simpler for you to move around on a mattress with bounce and pushback than one that sinks under your weight. Most firm mattresses allow for easy mobility, but there are those that excel in this area more than others.
  • Stable perimeter support makes it easier to get in and out of bed and sleep near to the edge of a mattress with good edge support. Firm mattresses, especially those with mid-range profiles, do well in this category.
  • While preferences vary, most individuals enjoy sex on a responsive surface that is easy to move around and provides adequate edge support. For this criterion, cooling and temperature control are also necessary.
  • An interesting relationship between body weight and preferred firmness has emerged in our research on mattress firmness. People who weigh at least 130 pounds and sleep predominantly on their back or stomach prefer firm mattresses.

Who is a Firm Mattress Best For?

When it comes to choosing a mattress, there are no hard and fast rules. We operate under the premise that everyone should select the option that most closely matches their unique set of requirements and preferences; this is our guiding concept. There are, however, basic patterns in which people benefit best from a firm mattress.

Body weight and primary sleeping position are both important considerations when determining the ideal firmness level. Over-230-pounders frequently prefer a firmer mattress since sinking too deeply into the bed might impair spinal alignment and create overheating. Firmer mattresses are more common in heavy people. Our team members that fall within this weight range prefer firmer mattresses to softer ones, according to our findings.

If you sleep on your back or stomach, you may require a mattress with a firmer feel to keep your abdominal and lumbar area from hyperextending, which can cause lower back pain. Taking your weight and primary sleeping position into account, the table below gives a general idea of the ideal mattress firmness level.

Sleeping Position

In order to get a good night’s sleep, you must find the right mattress firmness.

  • The hips and shoulders, which are common pressure spots for side sleepers, can be particularly troublesome if the mattress is excessively hard. For persons under 130 pounds, this is especially true.
  • In general, a firmer mattress is better for back sleepers because it prevents the lower back from sinking into a U-shape.
  • In terms of support, stomach sleepers and back sleepers are similar, although stomach sleepers frequently want a bed that is even firmer. This prevents them from sinking too far into their mattress because of their weight, a sensation that several of our team’s stomach sleepers have compared to “being swallowed” by their mattress.
  • Combination sleepers, who alternate between sleeping on their backs and stomachs during the night, benefit most from a firm mattress. Having a firm mattress can also make it easier to change positions at night by preventing you from becoming caught in the mattress.

Body Type

Your body shape and weight might also have an impact on how a mattress feels to you. When looking for a firm mattress, keep these things in mind.

Weighing more means putting greater pressure on a mattress, which causes heavier people to sink deeper into a bed. To put it another way, if you weigh less than 130 pounds, you may find a firm mattress to be unbearable, but someone who weighs over 230 pounds may find it comfortable. The demand for a firmer mattress seems to rise with an individual’s weight.

Body Weight – Video

To learn more about how your weight impacts the feel of your mattress, have a look at this video from the Sleep Foundation Lab.

How to Shop for a Firm Mattress Online

When you buy a firm mattress online, you save both time and money. Finding the perfect mattress is now easier than ever, thanks to a wide variety of products and the flexibility to search at your own speed at home.

We understand that purchasing a firm mattress without first testing its firmness may seem strange. In order to encourage customers to return their mattresses, many online mattress retailers provide free sleep trials. This allows you to utilize the mattress for a predetermined period of time, typically 100 nights or more, with no trouble. Because you can test the mattress at home, you’ll have a better idea if it’s right for you after the sleep trial.

Mattresses can be found for a fraction of the price at brick-and-mortar retailers because there is less overhead. Third-party sites like SleepFoundation.org frequently provide discounts or coupon codes to assist you get the best pricing from mattress makers. On our site, you can also find helpful information about mattress purchases and reviews.

Compression allows online retailers to ship “mattress in a box” for free, therefore delivery is nearly always included in the purchase price of a mattress online. The mattress will be delivered to your front door if you choose basic ground shipment. For an additional fee, White Glove delivery or installation may be available from some businesses. Ordering is as simple as a few mouse clicks, and payment options like credit card or PayPal make finalizing your transaction a breeze. A few retailers even provide financing options.

Buying Online vs. Brick and Mortar – Video

Learn about the advantages and disadvantages of buying a mattress online versus in a store by watching the video below.

Important Mattress Considerations

We understand how stressful it may be to shop for a new mattress. It’s easy for consumers to get bogged down in the minutiae of marketing campaigns and lose sight of the big picture. This is why we recommend focusing on the following aspects, all of which will influence your mattress buying satisfaction.

  • One of the most essential variables in a mattress’s function and long-term durability is its kind and materials. It’s helpful to know the type you’re most interested in so that you can narrow down your options and compare prices more effectively. This section has more information about different kinds of mattresses.
  • With the amount of time you spend sleeping on it, it’s an investment worth making. Then then, you’ll have to work within your financial constraints. It’s important to think about how much money you have available to spend on a new mattress and any related accessories, such as a new bed frame, sheets, and pillows.
  • Sharing a mattress with someone else might make it more difficult to sleep peacefully at night because of the possibility of being awakened by movement on the other side of the bed. However, the materials used to construct your mattress’ interior can have a considerable impact on whether or not motion transfer disturbs your sleep.
  • A firm mattress can nevertheless relieve pressure spots by providing enough cushioning. Even a small amount of give, when matched to your specific body weight, can aid in good spinal alignment.
  • Moving over a mattress with responsive components is often easier than moving across a mattress that sinks under your weight. This is a critical consideration for anyone who wants to be able to easily switch positions while sleeping or participating in sexual acts. In terms of movement, hybrid and latex mattresses offer the highest bounce.
  • For a good night’s sleep or sex, a firm mattress should have a consistent feel from edge to edge so that the entire surface may be utilized. It is also possible to sit on the bed’s edge without feeling like it is crumbling under you because of the strong edge support.
  • You may wake up in the middle of the night sweating if your mattress retains heat, which can contribute to a poor night’s sleep. Those who sleep hot should opt for a mattress that has anti-heat-building elements.

Types of Firm Mattresses

Focusing on the different sorts of mattresses is an excellent place to start if you’re not sure how to limit down your selections.

The design and performance features of each mattress category are similar, yet there are exceptions. To get a better idea of how a mattress would feel, look beyond the type and into the specifics of each brand and model.


Hybrid mattresses are defined by the presence of two distinct elements. Innerspring coils are used to build the support core at the bottom of the mattress. Foam, latex, microcoils, wool, cotton, and polyester are only some of the common materials used in the top layer of clothing, which is also known as the comfort system.

Most hybrid mattresses have a harder feel and excellent edge support, but the comfort system adds other benefits such as increased pressure relief and motion isolation, making them more than just “firm.” A substantial amount of cushioning and support can be found in most hybrids.


The innerspring support core is the primary component of an innerspring. An innerspring, as contrast to a hybrid, contains less materials above the coils. There may be a small quantity of foam or fiber fill, but this normally doesn’t make much of a difference.

Innerspring mattresses tend to have a stiff to extra-firm feel because to the lack of a sophisticated comfort system. Despite the fact that they often lack pressure relief and motion isolation, most innersprings consistently hold their shape. Innerspring mattresses are preferred by testers who weigh more than 230 pounds.


Latex is a rubber material that can be derived from tree sap or chemically synthesized. The inside layers of a latex mattress are exclusively formed of latex, and this natural rather than synthetic latex is most typically used in mattresses.

Latex is known for its resilience and bouncy nature, and it may be made in a variety of softness levels. In addition to being easy to get in and out of, a firm latex mattress provides some modest pressure relief. Latex mattresses tend to perform better than all-foam mattresses when it comes to moving around.


The air chamber in the center of an airbed’s support core can be filled or deflated to alter the firmness of the mattress. A smartphone or remote can be used to adjust the air pressure. One or more layers of comfort may be added on top of the support core.

With a press of a button, you may adjust the firmness of your airbed to suit your needs. The firmness of your airbed may be adjusted at the touch of a button, so you can find the perfect level of support. As a rule, airbeds perform admirably in our tests, especially when it comes to pressure alleviation.


Memory foam, polyfoam, fiber fill, or latex fill all the layers of a foam mattress. High-density polyfoam is typically used as the support core, with one or more layers above it providing the comfort system.

Additional Pressure Relief: Memory foam, in particular, compresses in reaction to the amount of weight given to it, allowing it to conform to the shape of the body. Pressure relief is enhanced even with a firm mattress, which can be especially beneficial to side sleepers. Side and back sleepers weighing at least 130 pounds tend to enjoy firm all-foam mattresses the most.

Accessories to Complement Your Firm Mattress

The first step in getting your bed set up to properly fit your needs is selecting a firm mattress. It’s a good idea to think about a few accessories to enhance your bed once you’ve purchased a mattress.


Make sure your neck is supported and aligned with your spine with the correct pillow. You’ll notice more of the pillow’s loft if you sleep on a hard mattress because the pillow won’t sink in as much. As a side sleeper you may appreciate the ability to adjust the pillow’s position under your head with feathers, down, polyester, or shredded foam or latex.

Thin pillows or models with a zipped cover that allow you to withdraw fill can be suitable options for back and stomach sleepers who often require lower-loft pillows. The loft is more stable when a pillow is constructed of a single piece of foam or latex. As long as the specified loft fulfills the support demands of the head and neck, these pillows can be used on a firm surface.

Mattress Toppers

A mattress topper can be a temporary solution if you want a firmer mattress but don’t want to spend the money on a new one. In most cases, the thickness of a topper ranges from 1 to 3 inches, and it is intended to be placed on top of your current mattress, tucked beneath your covers. Foam, latex, fiber fill, wool, or down are all options for mattress toppers.

This is an easy and inexpensive solution to improve the comfort of your mattress but it won’t be as lasting or trustworthy as a completely new mattress. To add insult to injury, any topper placed on top of a saggy or worn mattress will have a lower level of performance. This is why a topping is best suited for those who are on a small budget or only need a minor or short-term change.

How to Keep Your Mattress in Good Shape Longer

We’ve compiled a list of the ten greatest strategies to safeguard your mattress investment and avoid calamities.

1. Make sure your mattress is properly supported.

The appropriate kind of support for your mattress is critical, even if you don’t have to buy a matching box spring or foundation when you buy a new one. Materials are preserved and premature wear is avoided.

For more information, speak with the product’s creator or review the manufacturer’s warranty policy. Specialty mattresses such as memory foam and latex require a firmer support than traditional spring beds.

The center support bars on queen and king beds should be constructed to handle the weight of the mattress and the people sleeping on it. Mattresses that are too heavy or too light may require additional support from platform beds that have large slats.

Once or twice per year, you should look over your bed’s support to make sure there aren’t any cracked or damaged pieces that could affect your mattress’s longevity and comfort.

2. Use a mattress protector from the beginning.

Mattress protectors are one of the simplest and most effective ways to extend the life of your mattress.

In addition to protecting your mattress from spills and mishaps, a high-quality mattress protector reduces the amount of dust, debris, and filth that enters your bed.

Keeps skin oils and sweat from accumulating on the bed, prevents mildew and dust mites from accumulating, and helps to protect the materials inside your bed from deterioration. Many current protectors are just as comfortable as a fitted sheet, making cleanups a breeze when mishaps do occur.

3. Wash bed linens regularly.

Sweat, oils, hair, and skin cells are all shed while you sleep. Aside from the crumbs left behind by eating in bed, pets can bring in a variety of other items. Not only does this smell bad, but it can also foster bacteria and encourage the growth of dust mites if it makes its way into the mattress.

According to most housekeeping professionals, bed linens and blankets should be laundered once a week to twice a week. The cleanliness of your sheets is essential even if you’re wearing a mattress protector. The mattress protector should also be washed on a regular basis, following the instructions provided by the manufacturer.

4. Get pets separate beds to snuggle in.

Pets should not be allowed to sleep on your bed, but rather should have their own allocated beds.

Even well-groomed pets, like people, go outside, drool, and shed hair and cells, and this ends up on your bed as well. An otherwise decent mattress can be ruined by accidents caused by pets.

5. Rotate the mattress regularly.

Regardless of the material or the size of the mattress, rotating it on a regular basis is beneficial. While some manufacturers claim that rotation does not promote more even wear, the converse is also true: not rotating increases the likelihood of depressions and softening.

Rotate the mattress from head to foot every two to six months. It’s especially critical in the first several years while you’re getting used to your mattress.

6. No jumping on the bed!

Your mother was right when she cautioned you not to jump on the bed. Even though spring, water, and air beds may be more prone to damage from rough use than other types of foundations, frames, and foams, all of these can degrade more quickly if you are rough with the mattress.

7. Take care when moving your mattress.

When moving, avoid bending or folding your mattress to prevent damage. Instead, wrap it in plastic to keep it safe. Heavy-duty mattress bags can be secured with tape to keep dirt and wetness off the bed, and these also protect the bed from scuffs and scratches. Moving and box stores typically carry these bags.

If you’re transferring a mattress, keep it upright on its side so that it doesn’t fold or droop while being transported. Manufacturers often advise against dragging or moving the mattress using the cover’s grips.

8. Don’t bring home unwanted hitchhikers.

Once a bedbug has infiltrated, it’s nearly impossible to get rid of.

Always check the bed for symptoms of bed bugs when staying away from home, and keep luggage off the floor. Texas A&M University has some advice on how to avoid taking bedbugs back to your own house if you fear you have them.

Consider utilizing a bedbug-proof mattress encasement if you live in an apartment or in an area where these pests are prevalent. Mattress protectors, on the other hand, feature zippers that are impermeable and cover the entire mattress to prevent pests from making their home there.

9. Let the light in occasionally.

If you have a dry and sunny day once or twice a year, remove your mattress and let it air out for a few hours (though if bedbugs are possible, leave the cover on).

According to a Kingston University study, this may also help control dust mite populations by preventing excessive moisture from sleepers and humidity.

10. Follow manufacturer cleaning directions.

Every mattress should be cleaned on a regular basis in order to maintain a healthy sleeping environment and a long-lasting mattress.

Most mattresses should be vacuumed with a hose attachment to eliminate surface dust before following the stain removal and general cleaning instructions provided by many manufacturers.

Before changing the bed, spot treating stains with a moderate water and soap solution is an option. Foams should not be cleaned using powerful chemical cleansers, since they can weaken the foam’s structural integrity.

Vacuuming should be done every 1 to 3 months, depending on dust levels, allergies, or personal choice, and stains should be addressed as needed.

The essentials of mattress care and maintenance are the same, regardless of the type or brand of mattress you have.. To summarize, make sure the bed is free of debris, secure it from harm, support it, and rotate it regularly to promote even wear.

The lifespan of a mattress is highly variable, but by following some best practices, you can make sure that you get the most out of your investment and may sleep soundly for many years to come. For both traditional brick-and-mortar and new bed-in-a-box mattress firms, 10-year warranties are considered the industry standard.

Firm vs Soft Mattress: What's Best? | Mattress Clarity

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a firm mattress better for your back?

While one person’s back may benefit from a firm mattress, it may cause pressure points for another. If you sleep on your stomach, a hard mattress may not be the best option for your back. As a rule of thumb, a mattress that evenly supports your spine is the greatest for your back. Depending on your weight and the position you sleep in, you may require different levels of support.

According to our research, back and stomach sleepers who weigh more than 130 pounds need a firmer mattress. It’s possible for these groups to sink into the mattress’s core, resulting in a painful curvature of the spine.

Some side sleepers and those who weigh less than 130 pounds may experience pressure building if they sleep on a mattress that is overly firm. If you want to get a good night’s sleep, you’ll need to think about your mattress’s construction, weight, and sleeping style. Take full advantage of a mattress’ sleep trial to see if the firmness level suits your body type and preferences.

What mattress types are most firm?

Instead of all-foam or hybrid mattresses, people who prefer to sleep “on” their firm mattress can look at innerspring or latex options.

Pressure-relieving foam comfort systems are common in the latter two types, making them feel softer to the touch. There is normally a small comfort layer on innerspring beds, although latex mattresses are naturally more robust and bouncier than synthetic foams.

In general, mattresses that lack pressure-relieving comfort systems will feel harder than those that have substantial comfort layers. Firmness is not the same as pressure release. People who require a firm or extra-firm bed can benefit from a mattress that cradles the body.

What is the best firm mattress?

All of your sleep needs can be met with a firm mattress that provides just the appropriate amount of support. The first step in picking a mattress is to know that you prefer a firm mattress, but you also need to ask yourself more questions in order to locate the correct one.

We’ve found that sleep posture is a key aspect when testing mattresses. The pressure relief and support you require will be determined in part by your primary position or positions. Pressure points, aches, and pains can develop for side sleepers on a firm mattress with little to no pressure relief. People who sleep on their backs, on the other hand, may benefit from ergonomic zoning for more pelvic support, even though they require less pressure relief.

Are firm mattresses better for sleepers with back pain?

Having a mattress that is either too soft or too firm might lead to or exacerbate back pain. To select the ideal mattress firmness for their body type and preferred sleeping position, those with back discomfort should focus on obtaining an extra-firm mattress. When you sleep on a mattress that is too soft, your spine will be out of alignment, while a mattress that is too hard might cause compression of your joints and interfere with the natural curvature of your spine.

Is mattress firmness the same thing as mattress support?

When looking for a mattress, it’s important to think about both firmness and support. There is no guarantee that a firmer mattress is more supportive than a softer one; in fact, a firmer mattress does not necessarily mean that it is more supportive, either. In fact, a mattress that is too firm may be unsupportive, as it will obstruct your spine’s natural curve.

Take your weight and preferred sleeping position into consideration when determining the optimal firmness for your needs. If you need more support, instead of making your mattress firmer, think about investing in a bed with a strong support system, such as an ergonomically zoned hybrid mattress.

Helen Skeates

Helen Skeates

Lorem Ipsum is simply dummy text of the printing and typesetting industry. Lorem Ipsum has been the industry's standard dummy text ever since the 1500s, when an unknown printer took a galley of type and scrambled it to make a type specimen book. It has survived not only five centuries, but also the leap into electronic typesetting, remaining essentially unchanged. It was popularised in the 1960s with the release of Letraset sheets containing Lorem Ipsum passages, and more recently with desktop publishing software like Aldus PageMaker including versions of Lorem Ipsum.